2019 Jury
- Michelle Jacques, Chief Curator at the Art Gallery of Greater Victoria
- Al Miner, Founding Director/Chief Curator of the Georgetown University Art Galleries
- Ryan Rice, Kanien’kehá:ka of Kahnawake, Associate Dean, Ontario College of Art and Design (OCAD) University

Michelle Jacques
Chief Curator, Art Gallery of Greater Victoria
Al Miner
Chief Curator, Georgetown University Art Galleries
Ryan Rice
Associate Dean, OCAD UniversityPast Juries
2018 Jury
- Srimoyee Mitra, Director of Stamps Gallery, Stamps School of Art and Design (Ann Arbor, Michigan)
- Lisa Steele, Artistic Director of VTape and Professor, University of Toronto John H. Daniels Faculty of Architecture, Landscape, and Design
- Andrew Hunter, Senior Curator, Art Gallery of Guelph
2017 Jury
- Nancy Campbell, Independent curator and writer on contemporary and Inuit art (Toronto)
- Natasha Chaykowski, 2014 Middlebrook Prize Recipient (with Alison Cooley), Director, Untitled Art Society (Calgary)
- Rhéanne Chartrand, Aboriginal Curatorial Resident, McMaster Museum of Art (Hamilton)

Rhéanne Chartrand
Aboriginal Curatorial Resident, McMaster Museum of Art
Nancy Campbell
Curator
Natasha Chaykowski
Curator, Winner of 2014 Middlebrook Prize2016 Jury
- Melissa Bennett, Curator of Contemporary Art, Art Galley of Hamilton
- Robert Enright, Research Professor in Art Theory and Criticism, University of Guelph, and Senior Contributing Editor, Border Crossings
- Alison Cooley, 2014 Middlebrook Prize Recipient (with Natasha Chaykowski)
- Chair: Dawn Owen, Acting Director/Curator of Contemporary Art, Art Gallery of Guelph

Melissa Bennett
Curator, Art Gallery of Hamilton
Robert Enright
Professor in Art Theory and Criticism
Alison Cooley
Curator, Winner of 2014 Middlebrook Prize
Dawn Owen
Curator, Art Gallery of Guelph2015 Jury
- Katherine Dennis, Inaugural Middlebrook Prize Recipient (2013)
- Dawn Owen, Acting Director/Curator, Art Gallery of Guelph
- Jennifer Rudder, Associate Professor of Curatorial Studies, OCAD

Katherine Dennis
Curator, Winner of Inaugural Middlebrook Prize, 2013
Dawn Owen
Curator, Art Gallery of Guelph
Jennifer Rudder
Associate Professor of Curatorial Studies, OCAD
2014 Jury
- Chair: John Kissick, Director School of Fine Art & Music, University of Guelph
- David Balzer, Canadian Art magazine
- Erin Rutherford, Art Registration Consultant, Toronto
- Mentor: Shirley Madill, Executive Director, Kitchener-Waterloo Art Gallery

John Kissick
Artist and Prize Co-Founder
David Balzer
Associate Editor, Canadian Art
Erin Rutherford
Art Registration Consultant
Shirley Madill
Executive Director, Kitchener-Waterloo Art Gallery2013 Jury
- Chair: John Kissick, Director School of Fine Art & Music, University of Guelph
- Joanne Harder, Artist, Elora Centre for the Arts
- Ivan Jurakic, Curator, University of Waterloo Art Gallery
- Crystal Mowry, Curator, Kitchener-Waterloo Art Gallery

John Kissick
Artist and Prize Co-Founder
Jo-Anne Harder
Board Member, Elora Centre for the Arts
Ivan Jurakic
Curator, University of Waterloo Art Gallery